Skip to main content

Splitting User Stories vs. Rally's "split" feature (that has nothing to do with it!)

I recently came across a "split" feature in the popular Agile tool Rally that they recommend to handle unfinished work.
UPDATE: The above links don’t work anymore (apparently since CA acquired Rally). Rather than change the links (because I’m not sure if the new links correspond to the old articles I was responding to), I’m just going to share the new links:
  • https://help.rallydev.com/manage-unfinished-work#split
Below are my observations on the "Split" feature in Rally (following by a few excellent articles on Splitting User Stories):  
This has numerous problems:
1. Nothing to do with Splitting User Stories
It has nothing to do with "Splitting a User Story" which is an advanced but fairly well-understood field in Agile, and a tool for Product Managers to use in one of the two scenarios:
  • The Product Manager does it before an Iteration commences (i.e. during backlog creation or release planning) to create User Stories by business value that are right-sized, i.e. they can be comfortably implemented inside an iteration;
  • The Product Manager does it in Iteration Planning or in the middle of an Iteration to reduce scope by removing/simplifying acceptance criteria, in response to the actual progress of the team or other factors (including external factors).
2. A clumsy accounting gimmick
The "Split" feature in Rally is a misnomer that has nothing to do with the elegant and valuable technique of Splitting User Stories Agile teams use to deliver valuable product functionality iteratively. The Rally "Split" is a clumsy "accounting" tool (and a bad one at that), meant to attach value artificially to completed tasks and incomplete User Stories! It has nothing to do with splitting a user story intelligently by a Product Manager for business value.
3. Not doing User Stories anymore
Even if the goal is to do this so called "split" merely for accounting reasons, there are several problems with it:
  • You could be double counting the points! Some teams gets double the credit for a User Story when it doesn't finish it in an Iteration.
  • You're not doing User Stories any more. You just have two shells that wrap two groups of related tasks.
  • It establishes a bad precedent, incentivizes bad behavior and does not challenge a team to get better:  
4. Why bother with:
  • Spending time & effort thinking your User Stories through
  • making them follow the INVEST principle
  • keeping them small enough so that they can be DONE within an iteration
  • pushing the envelope on how far you can take your "Definition of DONE" (from Dev complete to Live in Production - and beyond)
  • responding intelligently to change in business or realities of a team's velocity
- when you can simply chop a story at the end of the iteration with one button click AND get credit for tasks completed (waterfall anyone?) that don't deliver any business value AND get double points for the User Story when it does get completed?
NOW, here are some really good articles and sources for good ways to Split User Stories:

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

The Wise & Persistent (a.k.a. Agile) Entrepreneur

"The whole problem with the world is that fools and fanatics are always so certain of themselves, but wiser people so full of doubts."
Bertrand Russell
The Dunning-Kruger effect explains the pervasive and perverse phenomenon where people with less competence rate their ability higher than do people who are relatively more competent.

The successful pursuit of any major goal in life requires many things including the much overrated Luck. In my mind, two qualities stand head and shoulders above everything else as absolutely essential to success:

Your ability to LearnYour Persistence
I've previously discussed how to improve your ability to learn.

Today I want to share with my fellow entrepreneurs my thoughts on persistence.

I'm sure you had enough lessons of persistence knocked into your head. And it may even be getting to a point where the word starts to lose its meaning. But the thing is, persistence will lead you to success only if you have a proportional ability to learn…

Gaand Mein Danda

If you don't know Hindi, you probably won't relate to it.

Turns out the youth culture in India is alive and well, and quite creative too.
Here's a hilarious- and a very melodious song, Gaand Mein Danda, from "Bodhi Tree", a student band from XLRI Jamshedpur.

Read along with the lyrics for total enjoyment ;)

Some of their other hits include:
- Sabka Katega
- Too Many Potatoes
- XL Ki Kudiyan

Here's some more on the topic if you're intrigued:
Sutta mil gaya
Swear word mil gaya