Skip to main content

Cricket, Racism, Hypocrisy, and Context

Check out this column on the recent racism row in cricket.

The 100+ comments below the article provide an excellent repost to the ill-informed, poorly written article.

Sure, Indians are as capable of racism as anyone. But the article got completely side-tracked into issues of *all* discrimination, not just racial discrimination.

‘Monkey’ and ‘donkey’ are commonly used in India to call someone ‘stupid’ or ‘a fool’. Growing up in India, we used to play ‘catch’ with a ball, where each time you miss you get ‘labeled’ which a letter from one of the following sequences: ‘M’, ‘O’, ‘N’, ‘K’, ‘E’, ‘Y’ or ‘D’, ‘O’, ‘N’, ‘K’, ‘E’, ‘Y’.

The bottom-line is this: what is offensive or racist is *context-sensitive*.

In the US, when a non-black person calls a black person ‘nigger’, it’s racist, but when a black man calls another black man ‘nigger’, it’s not.

Among Indians, friendly cussing happens in their primary language of communication. For some of my Hindi-speaking friends ‘gadhe’, ‘bandar’, ‘behan-chod’, ‘maadar-chod’ is not insulting, but calling them “son of a bitch”, “mother fucker” would definitely be. Yet for many of my English-speaking Indian friends, bastard or son-of-a-bitch are not insulting, but the literal “sister-fucker” might be.

One of the comments on Soumya’s article compared Indian crowds calling Symonds ‘monkey’ with how Inzamam was called ‘Aloo’ - both were meant to irritate the player. I can go step further and say that they were called ‘aloo’ or ‘monkey’ based on their *appearance* (Inzamam: aloo=fat and shaped like potato; Symonds: monkey=looking like a monkey). Definitely insensitive to call someone names based on their appearance, but that doesn’t automatically mean the appearance in question is racial. Potato is not racial. Monkey in India is also used to describe someone as ‘ugly’. Yes, when Indians refer to Blacks in a racist manner, they call them ‘kallu’ or might even compare them to monkeys - that’s definitely racist.

Which brings me to this: I grew up in India and have lived in the US for 17 years. And even though I follow cricket fanatically, I had no clue that Symonds was of a mixed race until this racism row. I never understood the furore about the ‘monkey’ chants in India directed towards Symonds- simply because I never saw him as a “black” man. Having learned of his mixed-race now, I can see how he might be offended.

On the other hand, I don’t get offended when my friends cuss me with the usual vocabulary, but even slight cussing from someone I don’t know well would be insulting. Fair enough if Symonds had told Harbhajan earlier that he finds it offensive to be called ‘monkey’, but he has to then reciprocate and not use any term that Harbhajan finds insulting. It’s a two-way contract, which became null and void, when Symonds broke it first.

Any which way you look at it, Symonds is a hypocrite and provoked Harbhajan unjustifiably in an attempt to bait him, knowing how hot-headed Harbhajan is. For his part, Bhajji is an idiot to fall for the bait, and he deserves a severe tongue-lashing from his captain and team management for dragging them into this muck. But his team-mates, BCCI, and Indian fans are correct in standing up in support of Harbhajan - *even if* he did call Symonds a ‘monkey’ *in retaliation*, because he was being deliberately baited, by Symonds and his “less than credible” teammates - Clarke and Hayden - who, at best may have *chosen to hear* what they wanted to hear, and at worst may have lied to “convict” Harbhajan.

In conclusion, let’s still not forget that *proven facts* only point to abusive or offensive language by Harbhajan - and by Symonds - not racist comments.

[Originally posted on my personal blog at muralikd.blogspot.com, February 01, 2008]

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Sex, Rape, and God

There's an interesting article in Washington Post that discusses the nuances and history of Mormon polygamy. I found the comments below it sufficiently compelling to respond. I'm reproducing here what I said there:

All this talk about what the religion or the sect says is a red herring in my view. The only issue is what is legal, and what should be illegal.

The core problem with this incident and others before it isn't whether polygamy is or should be legal.

* The problem is adults having sex with children *
* The problem is _systemic_ RAPE of children. *

No society should condone in any form sex with children.

Polygamy, Polyandry, Polyamory, Bigamy and any kind of sexual union between *consenting adults* is not the issue, and shouldn't be illegal in the first place.

The problem is that laws exist on books in several US states that make these various kinds of sexual activity illegal - including fellatio and sodomy - even between consenting adults.

Updating our legal s…

It's a slow economy- Let's talk about handshakes & picking up chicks

You know it's a rough economy when Guy Kawasaki is tweeting about picking up chicks and TechCrunch is blogging about handshakes & social etiquette and beating up dead horses.

But shouldn't these guys be talking about my friend's company that just got funded to do DNA computation in the cloud - or something like that?

[Originally posted on my personal blog at muralikd.blogspot.com, May 09, 2009]

My Experience (a kid's poem)

Here's a poem I wrote when I was in 8th grade in school

My Experience

Once upon a time, I had a little donkey
Whom I very lovingly, used to call Pinky
But in fact, he was very brown
And making a fine pair, I looked like a clown

Whatever we looked like, that does not matter
My story begins, as I grew fatter
Allow me to tell you, for your information
At that time, was I, a very poor washerman

One day, on Pinky, I loaded a huge clothes bunch
And on the top I settled, with my heavy paunch
Due to the mighty weight, his bones crunched
And the next minute, into the air I was launched

As I fell on earth, I started groans and moans
Nevertheless, the next thing I did was to check my bones
My limbs ached, and I felt very sick
Later on, I learned that the cause was Pinky's kick

After that experience so dim
I decided to become slim
And hence I advise you, never to become plump
For you too, as me, may receive many a bump!

[Originally posted on my personal blog at muralikd.blogspot.com, August…